Controversy Index

Movies where critics and audiences most disagree. Find the biggest critic bait, audience favorites, and polarizing films.

🍅 Critics Love It

RT much higher than IMDb — critics rate it higher

👥 Audiences Love It

IMDb much higher than RT — audiences rate it higher

1
Maquia: When the Promised Flower Blooms poster

Maquia: When the Promised Flower Blooms

2018
🍅
92.6
2
Grave of the Fireflies poster

Grave of the Fireflies

1988
🍅
91.5
3
Song of the Sea poster

Song of the Sea

2014
🍅
91.0
4
Wolfwalkers poster

Wolfwalkers

2020
🍅
91.0
5
The Second Mother poster

The Second Mother

2015
🍅
90.2
6
Before Midnight poster

Before Midnight

2013
🍅
90.1
7
Sunrise: A Song of Two Humans poster

Sunrise: A Song of Two Humans

1927

F.W. Murnau

🍅
89.9
8
Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse poster

Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse

2018
🍅
88.6
9
Casablanca poster

Casablanca

1943
🍅
88.5
10
Your Name. poster

Your Name.

2017
🍅
87.2
11
Soul poster

Soul

2020
🍅
87.0
12
Before Sunset poster

Before Sunset

2004
🍅
85.9
13
The Dark Knight poster

The Dark Knight

2008
🍅
84.9
14
The Dark Knight poster

The Dark Knight

2008
🍅
84.9
15
The Quintessential Quintuplets Movie poster

The Quintessential Quintuplets Movie

2022
🍅
84.6
16
Mommy poster

Mommy

2015
🍅
82.0
17
Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri poster

Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri

2017
🍅
81.9
18
The Aviator poster

The Aviator

2004
🍅
78.5
19
A Clockwork Orange poster

A Clockwork Orange

1971
🍅
77.8
20
Avatar poster

Avatar

2009
🍅
73.1
21
Burn After Reading poster

Burn After Reading

2008
🍅
71.0
22
A Beautiful Mind poster

A Beautiful Mind

2001
🍅
65.8
23
Synecdoche, New York poster

Synecdoche, New York

2008
🍅
61.5
24
The Invisible Guest poster

The Invisible Guest

2016
🍅
59.0
25
My Way poster

My Way

2011

Kang Je-kyu

👥
57.0
26
Redeeming Love poster

Redeeming Love

2022

D.J. Caruso

👥
56.0
27
Guillermo del Toro's Pinocchio poster

Guillermo del Toro's Pinocchio

2022

Mark Gustafson

👥
49.0
28
The Crow poster

The Crow

2024

Rupert Sanders

🍅
41.0
29
The Great War poster

The Great War

1959

Mario Monicelli

👥
41.0
30
Kraven the Hunter poster

Kraven the Hunter

2024

J.C. Chandor

👥
40.0
31
Pixels poster

Pixels

2015

Chris Columbus

👥
38.0
32
Christy poster

Christy

2025

David Michôd

🍅
37.0
33
Terminator Genisys poster

Terminator Genisys

2015

Alan Taylor

👥
37.0
34
Chappie poster

Chappie

2015

Neill Blomkamp

👥
36.0
35
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice poster

Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice

2016

Zack Snyder

👥
36.0
36
Mortal Engines poster

Mortal Engines

2018

Christian Rivers

👥
36.0
37
Transformers: The Last Knight poster

Transformers: The Last Knight

2017

Michael Bay

👥
36.0
38
The Plague poster

The Plague

2025

Charlie Polinger

🍅
35.0
39
Purple Hearts poster

Purple Hearts

2022

Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum

👥
35.0
40
Venom poster

Venom

2018

Ruben Fleischer

👥
35.0
41
Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales poster

Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales

2017

Joachim Rønning

👥
35.0
42
3 Days to Kill poster

3 Days to Kill

2014

McG

👥
35.0
43
After poster

After

2019

Jenny Gage

👥
35.0
44
Five Nights at Freddy's 2 poster

Five Nights at Freddy's 2

2025

Emma Tammi

👥
35.0
45
Fifty Shades Darker poster

Fifty Shades Darker

2017

James Foley

👥
35.0
46
Fifty Shades Freed poster

Fifty Shades Freed

2018

James Foley

👥
35.0
47
Anna poster

Anna

2019

Luc Besson

👥
33.0
48
Suicide Squad poster

Suicide Squad

2016

David Ayer

👥
33.0
49
Pillion poster

Pillion

2025

Harry Lighton

🍅
32.0
50
Gabby's Dollhouse: The Movie poster

Gabby's Dollhouse: The Movie

2025

Ryan Crego

🍅
32.0